Meet Our Staff

Meet Our Staff

Darryl McGuire

Auctioneer / Real Estate Salesman / Appraiser / Certified Estate Specialist

Phone: 330-348-1191


Darryl created himself a niche of marketing timber at auction; however he also markets Real Estate, personal property, antiques, business liquidations and much more! Darryl and his wife Dona reside on an 80 acre farm in Windham, OH. They are members of Bracevile United Methodist Church. They enjoy riding their horses and spending quality time with family and grandchildren.

When turning your assets into cash partnering with Darryl will pay great dividends! He is a creative thinker that is positive and believes in the auction method of marketing. Call Darryl today!

• Auctioneer / Real Estate Salesman, Agent II Seasons Realty
• Personal Property Appraiser CAGA
• Certified Estate Specialist CES
• State Licensed in Ohio & Pennsylvania since 1994
• Licensed Real Estate Agent since 1995
• Notary Public
• Over 35 years experience as a Hardwood Lumber Inspector
• Over 35 years with COBA Select/Sires as a AI Sales Rep. Technician Contractor.
• Over 35 years as a Custom Cattle Hoof Trimmer
• Independent Contractor for the National Hardwood Association Heat-Treat Auditor
Membership: Ohio, Pennsylvania & National Auctioneer Association, Certified Appraisers Guild of America, Member of the Local, State, and National Realtor Associations, Ohio & National Paint Horse Association, Braceville United Methodist Church, Garrettsville Masonic Lodge, Windham Board of Education, Maplewood Career Center Board.

Colleen Thompson

Auctioneer / Real Estate Agent / Marketing Director

Phone: 330-348-9149

Colleen is the daughter of Darryl and Dona McGuire and has been with the company since 2003. She attended Windham Schools and graduated from The University of Akron with a Bachelor’s of Science in Business Administration/Marketing. Colleen has been licensed in real estate since 2011 and became a broker with II Seasons Realty in 2015. She resides in Braceville, OH with her husband Rob and two children where they enjoy the outdoors, sports, cooking and entertaining.

Colleen has the training, skills and resources to successfully serve buyers. Her areas of auction expertise include, but are not limited to residential, agriculture, vacant properties, as well as antiques, firearms and farm equipment.

Jayme Gandee

Auctioneer / Realtor

Phone: Ohio Cell: 330-205-1915 North Carolina: 336-465-4826

3469 Lacy Hodge Dr.
P.O. Box 94
Sophia, NC. 27350
Visit Jayme Gandee Auctions website.

Jayme has been a licensed auctioneer in Ohio since 1994 and grew up in Minerva, OH. He had an extensive career in Ohio before him and his wife Cindy moved to Sofia, NC in 2008. Jayme is now licensed as both an Auctioneer and Realtor in Ohio and North Carolina. He has a great relationship with our Lord and Savior and has a love for farming and the outdoors.

Ed Hughes

Phone: 330-310-5598

Ed joined McGuire Auctioneers in 2010 but has been a licensed Auctioneer in Ohio since 1996. Ed and his wife Nancy reside in Cortland, OH. Ed has a passion for carpentry and spending time with his grandchildren. He owned and operated a successful auction house in Garrettsville, OH in the 90’s giving him a wealth of experience in the industry and he is a great addition to our staff.

Mike Tontimonia


Phone: 330-472-3878

Mike resides in Ravenna, Ohio with his wife Diane and is the Father of three daughters. Mike joined our staff as an apprentice auctioneer in 2005. Mike has 30 years in the educational field and retired from Maplewood Career Center as a Supervisor. Mike enjoys hunting and fishing, and writes articles for the several outdoor publications; one of which is The Outdoor Adventures, in the Farm&Dairy.

Joan Boytz

Cashier / Office Manager

Joan is the glue to our operation, she handles all our onsite auction management duties. She has always been an “auction goer” and she joined our staff in 1997. “Joan is like a second mother to me, she always has advice whether I want it or not, I love her,” says Colleen McGuire.

Shirley Broadwell / Vince Broadwell

Clerk / Set-up Crew

Sherly and Vince live in Braceville, Ohio and have been with our staff since 1997. Sherly is in charge of making sure everything gets written down and into our office correctly. Vince is our “detail” man. He helps set-up and work the day of the auction. “I have known Vince and Sherly for many years, we attend the same church and they are great people. For them to be part of our auction team is a blessing,” said Darryl McGuire.

Gene Henry

Set-up Crew

Gene comes to us with a wealth of knowledge in the industry. He is extremely experienced when it comes to the auction set-up and flow because he has been attending auctions since he was a boy. “When Gene is not working one of our auctions he is attending a competitors auction, and that is why we have put our trust in him when it comes to knowing the best way to accomplish something in our industry,” says Darryl and Jayme.

        Two Seasons Realty